Picnic at Hanging Rock

PLEASE NOTICE: THIS ENTIRE SECTION IS BEING UPDATED. I WILL BE POSTING IT EVERY SO OFTEN AS I MAKE PROGRESS. I'LL DRAW A LINE BETWEEN THE TWO SECTIONS. THIS WILL PROBABLY RESULT IN SOME THINGS MISSING BUT HOPEFULLY THAT WILL BE CORRECTED IN THE NEXT UPDATE.

SECTION I: GENERAL INFORMATION

First of all, this section of my website is undergoing i pretty major redoing. I'm redoing a lot of it and adding new things. That will take time so I'm going to keep this section up and it will change over time. It will be divided into over 20 sections, including a general introduction (this bit), material on the orignal book and its various printings, an analysis of the novel, stuff on the trailer and the movie itself, details about the movie, information about the movie script, various releases of the movie, articles about the movie, the play version, the televison series, you tube stuff on the movie, a few outtakes, reviews and synopses of the movie, an interview with Peter Wrir, the time effect, what actually happened to the girls, material on Australian literature, the real hanging rock and material on the first people.As you can see it will take me a good while to get all that done.

Picnic at Hanging Rock is a book by Joan Lindsay from Penguin Books, published in 1967 and reprinted various times thereafter. The book concerns the story of a girl's school outing in the Australian outback and the mysterious disappearances that occur during that outing. Various paranormal elements are present in the book, especially the manner in which time seems to stand still at one point. The book was later made into an excellent movie and a not-so-excellent Amazon series.

The events in the book and the movie are fictional. but the power of the movie and it's events is so strong that there are still some people that insist the events are real. Some people have written me taking extreme displeasure with that statement. An Australian journalist wrote me and told me he had done quite a bit of research through the newspaper files and there was nothing to show that the events really had happened. Although there is one source cited below that says the story is true, that source itself presents no facts to back it up.

What kind of facts am I talking about? Copies of newspaper articles or magazine articles from the time covering the events as factual; copies of police reports concerning any disappearance; copies of any reports turned in relating to any search teams that had allegedly been used to try and find the girls. Also, if the event had really happened, then there would have been others throughout the years that would have gone to Hanging Rock on their own to search for the girls, perhaps for a magazine article about the "anniversary" of their disappearance, but no such article or information has even been forthcoming.

Now, if someone can present me with copies of the above types of proof then I will be happy to add them to this site and give the person full credit. In a way it is a tribute to the outstanding quality of the film that some people still believe quite fervently that the events actually happened despite the lack of any actual proof of anything unusual actually happening on that date.

The original book.

This is an early version of the story, copyright 1967. I have two copies of the book and both have the same problem. The interior came lose from the cover.189 pages.

This is based on the actual original book which was released earlier but I havn't been able to afford so that is why I called it the 'original' book even thugh it was released some time after actual book was first published. I saw a copy on line that was over $300. Like I indicated, out of my price range. There's one page about Joan Lindsay and the usual page about publication. Since every book has that kind of page I won't bother mentioning it with the rest of the books.

I enjoyed the book but it does open the way to trying to figure out just what happens and that's where some fun is. The girls and a teacher disappear. That would be basic enough but in this case one of the girls re-appears later in pretty good shape. Then there's the thing about Edith screaming.

Edith's scream is quite important and I think overlooked some times. People don't normally scream unless something pretty major happens. Which means, logically, Edith did see something happen, but she can't recall what it was. This is similar to Irma's case. She was found but also can't remember anything at all. FOr those who favor the UFO hypothesis or something similar this is important. It indicates the possiblity of some kind of brain-wiping being done on the two girls. It also brings up the possibility that whoever or whatever sent Irma back rejected her for some reason so in addition to that we have the time situation where it was days before Irma appeared yet she seemed relatively in good shape.

So did Irma enter some kidn of time warp, stay somewhere else and then was sent back through or escaped from soemone and found her way back through. Yet she didn't remember anything that happened but was in bood shape which would indicate whe went through, was held on the other side for a short time and then sent back through? There's a problem with that, though, in that the girls who disappeared were at a certain point when they disappeared yet Irma is found at a slightly different location. Accidental or on purpose?

Then there's the problem of whether Sara was murdered or committed suicide. She was under trmendous mental pressure with her devotion to Miranda and then Miranda disappearing. She was also under great pressure from Mrs. Appleyard who treated her very badly. The combination of things could have driven her to kill heself. Yet Mrs. Appleyard told soemone Sara had already left the school when she definitely hadn't. Both possilities appear logical.

Meanwhikle, back to what happened on the rock. It's made clear there are snakes and bugs on the rock. We see that in the section of the film where the girls are asleep. Yet later the girls that ended up disapparing are walking barefoot. Doesn't make sense, does it. Knowing there were various creatures that could do them soem harm yet walking without shoes or socks.

This also brings up the issue of them removing their socks and the teacher, off on her own somewhere, removed everything but her underwear. Shey did they do that? Think about it for a minute. If the girls had planned to return to the school then they would have had to stop, get theri shoes and socks and put them back on and the techer would need to put her clothes back on. Time consuming and definitely a problem if anyone else from the school saw them before getting redressed. This makes the possibility that they were taken through a time warp or by aliens or something and didn't get the chance to get back.

So at the moemnt we have a time warp possibity and abduction by aliens as a possibility. Then there's the theory that they fell down into a hole (Chapter 18) and couldn't get out. I could understand one of the girls falling into maybe a deep hole but all three? And when would the teacher have appeared and fallen down the same hole? This also presumes that the distance they fell was far enoug to kill them or to injure them badly enough they couuld climb out.

Then there's that fact that Irma was in relatively good shaped when she got back which means one of two things: she went through a time warp twice, once to somewhere and again back to the rock and then either had some kind of time delay coming back or somehow was somewhere else for a time and was able to find food and water. Both seem to be stretching things a lot.

The red cloud/mist seen by Edith is also important. Just how thick was the cloud/mist/whatever? If it was a regular cloud why was it red? Were the girls zapped by some kind of ray and turned into a fine mist? The problem with that, though, is that one of the girls obviously survived and that doesn't make any sense either.

Then if you really want to get weird conside this. The Irma that returned was not the real Irma. She was a replicant made by aiens (?) and sent back through the portal to assueme a normal human life but to report back to her captors from time to time.There's probably a bunch more possibities that could be produced. The end point is that no one will ever know the excat truth (as long as you assuem that Chapter 18 is not true.)

Section 2: OTHER VESIONS OF THE ORIGINAL BOOK

These are copies of the book that are in my collection which include a few in other languages. There are other copies available but at least for now they are above what I can actually afford.

Section 2: The various Picnic at Hanging Rock books

Why buy copies of the story. Aren't all the books the same? The answer is no. Some books are the same, yes, but many are not. They might be in a different language. They might have a special opening. They will have a different cover. They will have been put out in a different year. There's a number of differences. I did a search and found out there around around 100 different copies of the book. I've only found twenty or third of those so what I have is only a part of what is actually there.

Published 1968. Published in England. Has a list of characters at the beginning.189 [ages

1961. Time Without Clocks about Joan Lindsay. Published in Australia. 216 pages.This book was written by Joan Lindsay who is the author of Picnic at Hanging Rock. It's an autobiography and goes into quite a bit of detail about her activities, her marriage, her trips, her friends, her houses and other things. It does indicate that she didn't like clocks, as the title of the book suggests.

It does not, though, have anything to do with Picnic at Hanging Rock, and that is something I wish the book had included. I would have liked to have seen some background information on why she wrote the book, where her inspiration came from, how she deals with the controversy (at least among some people) over whether or not the book is based on facts (no evidence has yet been produced to indicate that.)/h2>

It's somewhat interesting, but I feel it's only for a completist looking for anything even remotely connected to the book/film.

1977.French version. 320 pages.

1987. 67 pages. The Picnic at Hanging Rock play. List of people in it. Director's notes which are empty pages.The book above is one of the play books.Published in America.

1987. This is a must-have version of Picic at Hanging Rock. It's hardback, has photographs and colored illustrations and has sources of the illustrations. Published in Australia.

Published in 1991 in England. This book has a lot of extras in it including The Writer on writing, an Introduction, (with a lot in it), a reading log, the list of characters, the actual book, a glossary and a study programme.

1998. Pages but the pages are only printed on one side for some reason. There have been several plays based on the book/film and I don't know whether this is the first one, the middle one or some other.

2013. England. Has a list of characters.Marked 'Vintage Classics'. 196 pages.

2013. Secrets at Hanging Rock. I reviewed this for Goodreads and my review is as follows.The book takes a dual approach. One thread concerns events right after the picnic. Michael unfortunately is a prime suspect and he has to sit through an interrogation while the police, and the jury, try to find out just what happened. This is very rough on him. Also, the records of the previous investigation were destroyed in a fire. The second threat is about an archaeological did at the rock that uncovers an area that has skeletons in it. One of them is a female who was pregnant since the bones of the fetus are also found. Two other female skeletons are found and one male skeleton.(This is a point where the book is somewhat confusing. How did all of them end up in the same place at the same time? Did the girls and Miss Mc Craw enter the same space, find the skeleton of the guy and then get trapped? Why did they go into that cave-like space anyhow?>Mary Wade is the archaeologist and Jo is an assistant and also her lover. (That they were lovers is fine but I think the sex scenes are not really necessary in this particular book.)There's a lot of trouble for them as the local aborigine group tries to stop the excavation, claiming that the skeletons are their people (Yet it is firmly established in articles, etc, that the native peoples of that area consider it taboo to climb the rock because there are evil spirits there.)Also, the local group opposes the fact that females are on the rock.The way the team excavates the area is explained rather well and helps one to understand just how much work is involved in archaeology.There's a romantic problem for Mary and Jo and, again, I don't consider it germane to this particular story.Also, Mary does something which is basically is unethical as far as archaeological work goes.It seems very possible that the female skeletons are the missing people but it's left unclear whether they really are or not. (If they're not the missing people, though, then how did the skeletons end up there? Where did they come from and why do they just happen to be where the others had disappeared? It basically has to be them; there is no other reasonable explanation.)l only put up reviews like this for books that are not about the movie, tv series or play itself.

There are two versions of this book. The vovers are somewhat diffferent. The one with the frame around it is from 1987. It has an introduciton a commentary on the book, information about Joan Lindsay and information about the two writers for this edition. It has 58 pages and is from AUstralia.The other one is bigger, published in 2016, 32 pages and is from Australia. It also has an introduction and a section entitled The Final Chapter With The Mystery Solved?<.h2>

2004. Polish. 197 pages.

2005, Picnic at Hanging Rock is one of my favorite movies and when I found out about a written sequel to the movie I decided I just had to check it out. The story starts out in 1999 with a woman named Claire Hammond, who is sixty-six, being introduced. Then the book shifts to 1881, and throughout the rest of the book the times will change back and forth frequently, usually between 1900 and 1950, or 1950 and around 2000 or so.

The book establishes background information for Miranda, one of the girls involved in the Picnic at Hanging Rock events. We learn how Miranda came to end up at the all-girl boarding school. She becomes close to Marion and Irma.

The book ties in what happened to Miranda in 1900 with present-day Clair Hammond, and follows Claire's growing awareness that there is something unusual in her past. At the same time we are following Miranda, in 1900, from her disappearance at Hanging Rock to where she eventually ends up.

Claire finds some very disturbing information about her own past but, determined to follow the truth wherever it leads, she continues investigating (and her investigative technique is really quite good. She would do a detective proud.)

Love and heartache play major roles in the story as does Hanging Rock itself. The author presents a plausible explanation of what happened to the girls at Hanging Rock. Explanations of exactly how certain things happened are virtually impossible because there are some questions that we will never know the answer to.

Still, the book does a very good job of tying past to present, showing that the package it forms may not always be nice and neat, but it can make sense. It can also require personal sacrifice, though. Definitely a worthy addition to the Picnic at Hanging Rock legend.

This version is in Spanish. It is 307 pages long with an index at the end of the book. Its copyright is 2010.It starts with an introdution to Australian Gothic. This is followed by the story and then the index.

This is yet another printing of The Secret of Hanging Rock. Basically the only change from the other three above is the cover.

2017. 76 pages. Information about Joan Lindsay. Information about the story's adaptation for the stage. 76 pages.Published in London.

2017. First, this is a very neat book physically. The cover is very well designed, the book pages are thicker than average and there's a lot of photos in it. The book also is filled with information on Joan Lindsay and her husband. There's a little on the movie and the Picnic at Hanging Rock movie but the majority is biographical in nature.

It's also a little on the expensive side.

The main points of the book include:

The local tribesmen consider the lower part of Hanging Rock to be okay but the upper part to be evil, powerful and sacred. This is, of course, the part that the girls and the teacher disappeared from.

Some people that have explored the rock have said that they had the feeling that someone was watching them. Again, the local tribesmen have said that there are evil spirits on the rock.

Some of the tribesmen have said that the rock has 'unfinished business.'

Some of the names of people in the book/movie were based on real people's names.

The book discusses the importance of gardens to the Lindseys.

They had a lot of financial problems during their lives. They were artists and she was a writer so their income was not high and they tended to spend a lot on alcohol and related things.

In the movie watches seem to stop and this continues to this day. The cause of this is unknown. It obviously stopped watches in the movie and those watches had no electronic parts and it seems to continue to do that today even with watches that have electronic parts to them.

Clyde School is compared to the books Appleyard Cottage.

Both of the Lindsays had exhibitions of their artistic work.

Their marriage went through various rough parts but their remained married until the end.

The photos in the book are rather interesting. There is a bibliography but it's a 'select ed' one and lacks some of the books I've found (although there really aren't that many books about the movie or the original book.)

I think it would be interesting if a group of paranormal researchers with up-to-date equipment would do an examination of the Hanging Rock area. Also, part of that should be exposing a lot of watches to the area and see if the majority stop or if only a few stop or maybe not even any of them stop.

That the local tribesmen consider the rock to have 'evil spirits' is also significant. They have been there far longer than the Europeans and I don't think they would say an area is evil unless something had really happened there, at least once but most likely more than once.

Anyhow, it's a good book and worth getting..

Another 2017 book. Published in New York. 204 pages.

2017, published in Australia.21 chapers.

The book talks about the 18th chapter which was published after Joan Lindsay's death. It also gives a summary of what happened in the book. It discusses the hole opening up and taking the girls (which reminded me of what happened in The Pied Piper of Hamlin.) Even with that there is no actual final solution of what really happened to the girls in the long run.

(Keep in mind the original novel is fiction. Not fact. There is absolutely no evidence whatsoever for anything really happening and this is also covered in this book.)

The book also covers how the novel is similar to Alice in Wonderland. Alternative explanations are covered including whether Michael and Albert killed the girls. A landslide could have killed them (which would explain the red dust seen by Edith.)

The dichotomy between Nature and English Culture is discussed. Chapters are also devoted to individual characters, the book itself and the movie. What became of the cast and the crew is discussed along with whether or not knowing the 'final' final solution is really necessary.

The book is very readable, has some photos and is very interesting and well-done.

2018. Image is from the television series yet this is the standard book that has nothing to do with the television series. 189 pages.

All three of these books are from 2023. They are all forty pages long. six full pages of photos and two partial pages of photos. As you can see one is English, one French and one German.

This version is in Spanish. It is 307 pages long with an index at the end of the book. Its copyright is 2010.

2021. Yet another printing of The Secret of Hanging Rock.

This one is from 2025. It's another book in Spanish. There's an introduction on Australian gothic, then the original book and at the end an Index.

This book is from Australia. There is an introduction, A Fragment of Eternity. This is followed by the regular book.

The above books are ones that I actually have. There seem to be a good number that I don't, though. I have a few coming in but the rest are too expensive for me.

NOTE: THE FOLLOGING LIST IS NOT YET READY. AS i GET EACH SECTION DONE (THE ABOVE SECTION IS SECTIONS 1 AND 2) THE LINK WILL WORK BUT FOR NOW SOME WON'T.

Section 3: DVDs, audiobooks, laser disc

Section 4: Looking at the orignal script

Section 5: Plays based on the movie

Section 6: The television series

Section 7: You Tube videos and ot ehr topics

Section 8: Disapproval by the native Australians

Section 9: Links to articles about Picnic at Hanging Rock

LINKS

Karissa Reads Books

Wikipedia

Is Picnic at Hanging Rock based on a true story?

A Beguiling Story

Picnic at Hanging Rock Feeds Unfathomable Mystery

Joan Lindsay’s mysterious ‘Picnic at Hanging Rock’

Picnic at Hanging Rock is just as unsettling and relevant 50 years on

The True Story Behind ‘Picnic At Hanging Rock’

What really happened to the girls at Hanging Rock?

On the unbpublished ending of Picnic at Hanging Rock and other mysteries